Welcome To MovieAnimeX ! From the cursed kingdom of Demon’s Souls to the dying fire of Dark Souls III, the nightmare of Bloodborne, the war-torn Japan of Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice, and the shattered cosmos of Elden Ring, each protagonist starts as nothing — and ends as something terrifying.
👉If you like this review and want to help us grow financially, then you can do it by purchasing products in the blog; they are affiliated links. It gives us commissions but no extra cost to you. The affiliated links are indicated by pointing emoji.
👉Bloodborne Hits – PlayStation 4
This ranking is strictly lore-based, not gameplay difficulty. We are comparing:
- God-slaying scale
- Final boss hierarchy
- Ascension beyond humanity
- Cosmic influence
- World-altering impact
Let’s rank every Soulsborne protagonist from weakest to most powerful.
Table of Contents
7 – Slayer of Demons (Demon’s Souls)
Game: Demon’s Souls
The Slayer of Demons is where it all began. In the kingdom of Boletaria, this silent warrior defeats powerful demons such as Flamelurker and the Dragon God before confronting the ancient Old One.
On paper, sealing an eldritch god sounds extraordinary. But context matters.
Many of the Slayer’s victories rely on environmental advantages. The Dragon God, for example, is defeated using siege weapons rather than pure strength. Even the Old One is more of a dormant cosmic parasite than an active, reality-dominating deity.
The scale of the world is also relatively contained. Boletaria is collapsing, but the universe itself is not at stake. There’s no multiversal implication, no reshaping of metaphysical laws.
The Slayer is strong — undeniably. But compared to what comes later in the Soulsborne lineage, this is the smallest stage.
Lore Verdict: The pioneer of god-slaying, but limited in cosmic scale.
👉Demon’s Souls – PlayStation 5
6 – Bearer of the Curse (Dark Souls II)
Game: Dark Souls II
The Bearer of the Curse operates in a deeply philosophical era of the Dark Souls mythos. Instead of simply linking or extinguishing the flame, this protagonist seeks a way to break the cycle entirely.
They defeat beings such as The Rotten, The Lost Sinner, King Vendrick, and Aldia — figures deeply tied to the fading Age of Fire. Most importantly, the Bearer absorbs immense quantities of souls, reaching an extraordinary level of spiritual density.
However, many of these foes are fallen rulers or distorted remnants of past glory. They are powerful, but not prime gods at their peak. The Bearer’s greatest achievement lies in escaping the curse’s inevitability rather than overthrowing a cosmic pantheon.
In terms of metaphysical impact, the Bearer is revolutionary. But in raw, god-tier combat scaling? Slightly below others.
Lore Verdict: Curse-breaker and cycle-defier, but not yet a universe-shaping force.
👉Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin – PlayStation 4
5 – Chosen Undead (Dark Souls)
Game: Dark Souls
The Chosen Undead is legendary.
They defeat Seath the Scaleless, Gravelord Nito, The Witch of Izalith’s legacy, and ultimately Gwyn, Lord of Cinder — the god who ushered in the Age of Fire.
Linking the First Flame reshapes the entire destiny of the world. This act sustains or prolongs reality itself. That alone elevates the Chosen Undead into mythic status.
However, Gwyn at the time of the final battle is a hollowed shell of his former self. His power has faded significantly. The Chosen Undead triumphs, but not against prime Gwyn.
Later entries in the trilogy escalate power levels even further. Still, the Chosen Undead laid the foundation for all that followed.
Lore Verdict: Flame-linking legend, but surpassed by future accumulations of power.
👉Dark Souls Remastered – PlayStation 4
4 – Wolf (Sekiro)
Game: Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
Wolf is different from every other protagonist here.
While others absorb souls or harness cosmic forces, Wolf relies on mastery, immortality, and relentless combat precision. Through the Dragon’s Heritage, he gains resurrection abilities. He parries lightning, deflects bullets, and defeats the Divine Dragon itself.
He also overcomes Isshin Ashina at his absolute peak — arguably one of FromSoftware’s most formidable warriors.
However, Sekiro’s scale is intimate. It is a story of loyalty, war, and personal transcendence — not cosmic annihilation. Wolf does not dismantle a pantheon. He does not rewrite reality. He does not ascend into a higher being.
But in pure combat capability? He may be the deadliest duelist on this list.
Lore Verdict: Supreme warrior, unmatched in skill — but limited in cosmic influence.
👉Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice [Game of the Year Edition]
3 – Ashen One (Dark Souls III)
Game: Dark Souls III
The Ashen One represents the absolute climax of the Dark Souls power curve.
Their final opponent, the Soul of Cinder, is not a single entity — it is the embodiment of every previous Lord of Cinder combined. That includes Gwyn and all who linked the flame after him.
Defeating the Soul of Cinder means overcoming the accumulated might of an entire era.
The Ashen One also slays Darkeater Midir, an ancient dragon empowered by abyssal corruption, and potentially ushers in the Age of Dark or a new painted world — reshaping reality’s direction.
By scaling alone, the Ashen One surpasses the Chosen Undead. They fight at the literal end of time, when reality itself is collapsing.
Lore Verdict: The peak of the Dark Souls trilogy’s power structure.
👉Dark Souls 3 The Fire Fades (PS4)
2 – Tarnished (Elden Ring)
Game: Elden Ring
The Tarnished operates on the largest stage FromSoftware has ever created.
In the Lands Between, the Tarnished defeats demigods empowered by fragments of the Elden Ring — including General Radahn and Malenia, Blade of Miquella. These are not faded remnants. They are near-prime legends.
The Tarnished ultimately defeats the Elden Beast, a manifestation of the Greater Will’s cosmic authority. This is not just a god. It is an emissary of an Outer God — a force that governs reality itself.
And then comes the defining moment: the Tarnished becomes Elden Lord or reshapes the metaphysical order entirely through alternative endings.
Unlike the Ashen One, who sustains or ends a cycle, the Tarnished rewrites the laws governing existence. The scale is astronomical.
With DLC expansions introducing even more prime-level threats, the Tarnished’s power ceiling rises dangerously close to the top spot.
Lore Verdict: Reality-rewriting conqueror of demigods and cosmic entities.
1 – Hunter (Bloodborne)
Game: Bloodborne
The Hunter stands alone.
In Yharnam’s nightmare, the Hunter defeats Great Ones — beings existing beyond human comprehension. Rom, the Orphan of Kos, and ultimately the Moon Presence fall.
But the most important distinction is not victory.
It is ascension.
In the true ending, the Hunter transcends humanity and becomes an infant Great One — a cosmic, eldritch being beyond mortal limitations.
Every other protagonist either maintains a cycle, ends a cycle, or claims a throne.
The Hunter evolves.
They do not merely defeat gods. They become one.
The Great Ones exist on a plane far removed from fire-linking lords or demigod warlords. Their influence spans dreams, dimensions, and reality-warping insight.
That level of transformation places the Hunter at the top.
Lore Verdict: The only protagonist to fully ascend into an eldritch cosmic entity.
👉Bloodborne Hits – PlayStation 4
Could the Tarnished Surpass the Hunter?
With expanding lore and potential future content, the Tarnished may yet close the gap. If Outer God scaling increases further, we may need to revisit this ranking.
But as of 2026, based strictly on lore strength, ascension, and cosmic hierarchy, the Hunter remains the most powerful Soulsborne protagonist.
The debate will continue — and that’s exactly why FromSoftware’s worlds remain unforgettable.